Sons of Town Hall are a truly, truly unique duo. They perform majestic folk music, mixing themes of loneliness and wanderlust with a strange magical realism and instrumentation worthy of film score. Their vocal performances are genuine, selling the tender emotions and awe at the world they’re encountering. While I generally think musicians think songs about travel are more interesting than their audiences do, “Of Gods And Ghosts” is an exception to that. It’s an adventure with surreal highs and touching lows, not a slog for work. They’re also a historical fiction comedy act, allegedly traveling the world on a raft. They send up the very earnest sorts of songs and performances they deliver so well. Their nonsensical companion podcast, paired with their album, creates a new way of experiencing music.
“We basically created a mythic backstory for ourselves. We travel the world on a raft we built with our bare hands. We look like we stepped out of the cast of Gangs of New York,” David Berkeley, who plays Josiah Chester Jones, explained. “I wear a top hat and Ben’s in a bowler and we have different names. We deliver these deadpan stories between our songs about the adventures and misadventures that we got into that led to the writing of our songs. The result is that the show is part performance art and part concert.”
Most folk music fans have been to a concert where an artist takes a moment between songs to tell a story about what their audience is about to hear. There may be a joke, there may be some tugging at heartstrings, but the story is usually true.
“To twist the genre a little bit, to still have that song, but to present the most outlandish setup story is so funny,” said Berkeley. “We really believe that what we’re saying could’ve happened. I think that’s the key to all good fiction. You’re not thinking about it like you’re making up a story.”
“It could be the time we spent in New Orleans falling in love with a trapeze artist, said Ben Parker,” who plays George Ulysses Brown. “We’re these hapless but hopeless underdog in all the stories. We’re pretty useless at most things, which is why we never stick around long.”
That these two came together at all is a result of Berkeley, an American, touring under the same management in Parker’s native England.
“We fell really desperately in love and it’s been romance ever since,” said Parker.
“It was right around the time when I discovered the British Office, and when I met real Brits, I just found them so funny,” said Berkeley. “I credit Ricky Gervais for the band coming into existence.”
The two were separated during Covid, unable to produce music a continent apart. Instead, they worked on a podcast that pushes sketch comedy to its limits.
“We were keen to dive into the world we were creating on stage, but obviously we couldn’t be in the same room together,” said Parker. “We started fleshing out some of the stories, some of which had just come from the songs, some had come from the ridiculous banter between our songs live.”
There’s clearly a bit of research that goes into the project. The costumes are ridiculous, but the pair worked on developing some period accurate language. When visiting an interesting location, they decided to bring it into their lore.
“We were in North Adams playing and we learned about this rail tunnel, which was at that time the longest rail tunnel in the world. It was called the Devil’s Backbone,” explained Berkeley.” And since we were there we decided we’d write a song about our digging the tunnel because it was of the period. We wrote the song and of course it was really funny to say it was good to be back in North Adams after 120 years.”
There’s a very strange balance between the two aspects of their art. The music is genuinely beautiful and rarely amusing. I discovered their podcast only after having determined that their concept album alone was touching and original enough for a spot on the show.
“We take the music very seriously. The songs are very beautiful, I hope,” said Berkeley. “We work really hard on the harmonies and the guitar parts are really intricate. If the songs were as bad as we are in our stories, it would be a train wreck.”
The songs are meant to drive home the emotions the characters feel, be it the exhaustion and terror of a difficult job or the awe of discovering Antarctica. They deliver a magnificent set of instructions for building their mythical raft, including items of questionable usefulness like “an old barn door” and elevated purpose like “a coil of rope and faith.” When one of their characters sings “If I had more to lose/that too would be gone,” the delivery is sincere enough to generate empathy. And when their 70s folk harmony style music unleashes a line like “There’s a beast I’ve learned lurks down inside us all/Hold me down too long/gonna push down the walls,” it feels understandable and part of a story arc worthy of the big screen. “Sirens,” one of the best songs about life on the road I’ve ever heard, is a wrestle between the temptation of settling down and the drive to keep pursuing a passion at the expense of comfort. The Odyssey will be in iMax theatres quite soon, but even Sir Christopher Nolan will struggle to deliver that scene as well.
How it pairs with the comedy is tricky. I’d argue with anyone who says “Of Gods And Ghosts” fails to work as magical, metaphorical, and emotionally resonant. I don’t think I’d stop anyone from skipping the podcast if they determine the banter isn’t for them. The music holds up on its own, though some lines make more sense with further explanation.
There are great moments on the podcast to be sure. The comedy can range from a violent naked man emerging from a bale of hay, to bad accents, to lines about the reporter supposedly keeping track of our heroes being a hit with the ladies. It’s all cringe, as intended. The two central characters display an emotional innocence that makes their antics endearing, but real tragedy unfolds around them. Sometimes because of them.
“People don’t want to be on this flat line of emotion,” said Parker of their unusual mix of genres. “They want to be on this up and down.”
“We can tell stories that might actually be pretty sad, but because they’re framed, there’s always this levity to them,” said Berkeley. “People are kind of laughing and crying at the same time.”
I imagine that this would work best in the immersive atmosphere of a live show. Still, it’s a truly singular creative output, and a more memorable use of lockdown than baking sourdough.
The band is named after a real raft built by a real man who sailed the Atlantic on it. In the 1990s, that is, not a century earlier like on the album. The nod to history and the idea that Berkeley and Parker went out and did research to ground their insane story in some sort of plausible parallel is actually one of the funniest parts about their act. They can effortlessly justify nonsense in a way that makes it sound almost reasonable. The crisscrossing of oceans the characters do had a bit of resonance for the songwriters, as well.
“It parallels a lot of our real life as touring musicians too,” said Berkeley, “There is a sense of a band as a little floating island out there.”
Just to get a sense of what a show might be like, I asked Berkeley and Parker to transform into Jones and Brown and speak to me in character. They are funny. They marvelled at encountering a whale on their voyage and spoke of their reverence for ocean life, but seemed nonplussed by the fact they ate seagulls to survive.
“They were the only things we didn’t respect,” said Brown. Well, Parker, but you get the picture.
In character, he justified their unique way of life in a line that could have actually come out of the office.
“As you lay on your deathbed, you’re going to think about the people that you met,” said Brown with a straight face. “We’re keen to voraciously ride our way through as many options of human as possible.”
Above is the full episode as aired on WUSB’s Country Pocket, including both my interview with Sons of Town Hall and the songs we discussed, starting with Sirens. The interview begins with the third video in the playlist. The first half I speak to the artists as always, but later on I speak to their fictional counterparts. You can hear the show live alternate Wednesdays at 8am on WUSB 90.1 FM or check the blog to watch it as a YouTube playlist. Visit http://www.WUSB.fm and https://sonsoftownhall.com for more.