Josh Fortenbery wrote “Heaven’s Above” as a “eulogy for nihilism.” He’d spent most of his life seeing a broken system he couldn’t fix and living for himself. Now, seeing a new generation spring forth from his friends and family, he’s decided he has to at least try to improve his community despite knowing full well he doesn’t have any of the answers.
“At some point it becomes impossible to stand on the sidelines and watch things fall apart without recognizing that you’re somehow complicit,” said Fortenbery. “I’m not sitting here on a cloud above it all, I’m in the middle of it.”
Fortenbery’s album Tidy Memorial, with songs titles such as “Is It Me?,” grapples with current and pandemic era politics primarily through self examination and calls for understanding. There are a few songs on the album, “Steven,” for example, that show Fortenbery is not neutral in any discussions over justice. But he tends to focus more on structural problems and individual solutions. “I could argue with a statue and still think I won,” he sings in “Groundhog.”
“I think we all intuitively understand that it’s becoming more difficult to talk about meaningful things without devolving into name calling,” said Fortenbery. “Worldwide, we’re all dealing with the same information bubbles and same social media algorithms that push us into these media diets that are tailored to our own suspicions and biases.”
“Nobody cares like I do/But I’m pretty sure you think/that nobody cares like you,” sings Fortenbery in “Heaven’s Above.” It doesn’t seem like he’s calling for a change in viewpoints on behalf of either party, rather a little bit of empathy and recognition of similarities. He’s smart enough to realize nothing will change until those bubbles and silos start breaking.
“Is there a world in which enough people realize they’re being lied to? Maybe that makes folks start to ask more questions,” said Fortenbery. “Maybe this is all very optimistic, but I’ve found it more difficult to lean into complete hopelessness because it’s harder to get out of bed that way.”
If “Tidy Memorial” calls for greater dialogue between opposing sides,“Poppy’s Waltz” is a recognition of both how easy and difficult that can be. On the one hand, Fortenbery had a good relationship with his grandfather and found many admirable traits in the man, as the lyrics suggest. Still, they disagreed on the topic of Israel and had to avoid the topic. “Love can’t bridge all gaps,” Fortenbery admits.
“Most American Jews his age came to view the foundation of the state of Israel as destiny and a safe haven. I’ve grown up with a different set of life experiences. I’ve always viewed it through the lens of apartheid, separation, oppressive state control, treating people the way you don’t want to be treated,” Fortenbery said. “It was less of a disagreement and more of a taboo in that household because there was no way to see eye to eye. As some of the lyrics give away, I’m prone to think I’m correct; I still think I’m right about this one. That doesn’t mean that he was a bad person. I still think you can live your life in a way that shows you’re compassionate, kind, caring, while holding some beliefs that I might find difficult to accept.”
Years into a tragic situation that saw more than a thousand Israelis kidnapped and murdered and tens of thousands of Palestinians killed and Gaza flattened, the topic remains extraordinarily difficult to address. The Trump administration has essentially taken partial control of universities on the basis that they didn’t do enough to protect Jewish students from those protesting Israel. Support for Palestine, or at least opposition to the Israeli government, is now a mainstream view in the Democratic Party. Trump takes credit for having secured a ceasefire in the region, but American bombs are still landing in Gaza. It’s difficult enough for me to talk about situation this fraught and complex, but I’m not being asked to weigh in. Fortenbery is.
“It feels to me like a tricky conversation to enter in the regular world as a Jewish person. There certainly has been an increase in antisemitism, though I don’t equate anti-Israel sentiments with antisemitism,” said Fortenbery. “It’s not like I have any particular set of skills that would fix anything, but it seems like there’s an expectation of you just because of your born identity.”
Fortenbery passes some judgement on local police on “Steven,” which describes a tragic confrontation between them and a homeless Alaskan. But he’s mostly asking questions, sharp as they may be: “Is that life?/Is that it?/Something you can take away and say he deserved it?”
“He was a pretty quiet, gentle guy, but like many people who are homeless had mental struggles. He had this big beautiful malamute dog who always wanted a pet,” said Fortenbery. “The police wanted to question him in conjunction with some alleged assault that happened downtown. He was having an episode and always carried a knife with him. They claim he took a step toward him and he was shot and killed. This is not a unique story to Juneau. This happens everywhere. I don’t know what the right answer is but certainly we’re not doing enough.”
With tough questions like this, with political conditions worsening throughout the world, with Alaska quite literally entering perpetual darkness, Fortenbery admits he may be spoon-feeding himself positive thoughts. But he’s forming them through positive actions and involvement in his local and music communities. Even the negatives he focuses on in his music aren’t representative of all his thoughts.
“We can make people feel. We can make beautiful art. We have a nice afternoon together. We can go out and provide food to people who need it. It’s not hard to go out and volunteer at a shelter for the afternoon. There’s a bunch of little human interactions that are available to everyone. If I just read the news, then I’d be sucked into that pit of despair that if you just listen to my songs, you’d think I’m in all the time,” said Fortenbery. “But music is my way to process the things that upset me so that hopefully when I venture out into the world, I’m not a miserable bastard all the time. Hopefully, I’ll find a little bit of beauty and joy because this is the only chance we’re going to get at living.”
Above is the full episode as aired on WUSB’s Country Pocket, including both my interview with Josh Fortenbery and the songs we discussed, starting with “Heaven’s Above,” which seeks self improvement in an increasingly absurd political environment. The interview begins with the second video in the playlist. You can hear the show live every Monday at 4pm on WUSB 90.1 FM or check the blog to watch it as a YouTube playlist. Visit http://www.WUSB.fm and https://www.joshfortenbery.com for more.
